Payment By Performance: Commentary on payment mechanisms for policy outcomes

Gary Sturgess, June 2010



'If policy analysts carry bumper stickers, they should read: Payment by Performance.'

The great American political scientist, Aaron Wildavsky, wrote these words almost forty years ago, and yet politicians have only recently begun to give them serious attention.

For the most part, governments pay for process and promises. Despite ambitious statements about anticipated policy outcomes and annual budget papers, daily news papers remind us that what governments buy from their agencies, most of the time, are inputs – quotas of teachers, police officers and hospital beds.

And public servants are inclined to measure how well they have complied with the rules, since due process is safer and easier to deliver than due performance.

The vast majority of public service contracts are little better – specifying inputs or at best low-level outputs, hemmed in by policy settings that make bold innovation difficult, if not unthinkable.

In recent years, this has begun to change, with the emergence of new contract models, where government pays when there is clear evidence that an outcome, or at least a high-level output directly linked to that outcome, has actually been delivered.

The attractiveness of such a model to Ministers and to Treasuries is not difficult to explain. Done well, it is not difficult to explain to the public at large. And yet the challenges are immense.

It is often difficult for public officials to state clearly in advance what the key outcomes of a particular programme are – to reduce the complexities and uncertainties of the future policy environment to a single set of performance conditions.

Download the full article
Payment by performance makes complete sense and has been part of the political rhetoric for forty years, however, it is difficult to achieve.

Related articles

Marching Towards Inclusivity: Bridging the Gap Between the Armed Forces and Society

How can the UK Armed Forces harness diversity to attract, recruit and retain future talent?
1st March 2024

Breaking Point: Attitudes towards ‘career breaks’ across four countries & how to create a system fit for purpose

15th December 2022

User Experience in Government Services: The Need for a Unique Approach (Saudi Arabia)

The Serco Institute's new report takes a deep dive into user satisfaction with government services, challenges with measuring it and why a new approach is needed.
26th July 2022