Good People, Good Systems: Former public servants speak about delivering public services in the private sector

Emma Reddington, June 2004

Foreword

 

This project had its origins seven or eight years ago, when a former colleague from the New South Wales Public Service asked me to explain what was different about the private provision of public services: ‘You are delivering the same services, mostly with the same people. Why can you do what we can’t?’

At the time I was still living in Australia, and on my periodic visits to the United Kingdom, I would ask this question of Serco’s contract managers who had previously worked inside government: ‘What is different about delivering public services in the private sector?’ The answers that they gave were much the same as those provided by the respondents to this survey – a combination of increased autonomy and increased accountability.

The problem with modern government is not the people but the systems. Competition and contracting create a different decision-making environment that enables these people to get on with the business of delivering efficient and effective public services. This phenomenon is by no means confined to the English-speaking world. In his recently- published account of the highly-successful privatisation of Japanese National Railways, Yoshiyuki Kasai, now the President of JR Central, comments that:

Reduced political and bureaucratic interference in the management was an important prerequisite for success. People, however, do not change overnight. What you see is what the workers have always been. In the process of privatization, they were just able to express themselves more freely.

‘Good People, Good Systems’ is a pilot study based on a small but significant sample of Serco’s contracts. It provides insights rather than answers. And it is published in the hope that it will stimulate government, industry and academic institutions to undertake further research in this area, drawing on the experiences of a much wider range of companies and public services.

Download the full article
Former public servants speak about delivering public services in the private sector and the decision-making environment that enables them to get on with the business of delivering efficient and effective public services.

Related articles

The Structure and Future of the UK Public Services Market

The public service industry in the UK – that part of the market made up of non- government suppliers – accounts for almost 6 percent of GDP and employs some 1.2 million people. However, virtually nothing is known of the supply side of this market.
4th December 2012

Integrated Commissioning: Building a better model for the delivery of social value through diverse networks of local providers

Decentralisation has been identified as an important key to unlock more productive and responsive public services. The closer the services are to service users, the more accountable they are for addressing users’ diverse and individual needs. As such, increasing the impact of public services means devolving control and providing more choice.
30th June 2012

Frugal Innovation: Learning from social entrepreneurs in India

Over the last 60 years, innovation and improvements in India's public services have frequently emerged in the absence of state intervention or involvement. Social enterprises have stepped in to address the challenges where the government has failed.
29th February 2012